I have come to the conclusion that editing is like a painful, surgery. It feels something like evisceration when you start, ripping out the guts of your soul, poured out onto the page. No matter how long you’ve worked on the piece, or how long you’ve set it aside, if it’s one you’ve truly connected to, then there are some parts of it that hurt to think about letting go. Oh, the absurd number of adverbs or the realization you structured an entire paragraph with simple sentences is easy enough to edit and correct. There’s no pain in letting go of “viciously” and changing it to something else to get your intent across. It doesn’t hurt to reconstruct your sentences in a new and varying way. That’s more like a face-lift after decades in the sun or a nose-job after one too many breaks, you can see with ease how it will help.
What starts to hurt is when you realize that this scene, the one you spent days to get just right, the one you can see and hear in your head, is probably extraneous. That no matter how lovingly crafted it is, the scene simply doesn’t move the story forward. It doesn’t reveal anything crucial. It can be cut and tighten the novel as a whole and your readers will never miss it, never know it was there. But you will. You do. You take it out because you know it’s better for the novel. You cut scenes, clip moments, shorten conversations that delve deep under the surface of your characters, but it hurts. They aren’t bad. They aren’t poorly written. They just don’t fit, not the way you thought they would when you first wrote them.
It feels like evisceration, but it’s more like necessary surgery, cutting out potential growths that could turn cancerous and poison the novel as a whole, make it fail, drag your reader’s attention away. Enough of those little moments, extraneous scenes, could mean the death of your novel on some agent’s desk. So you cut, no matter how it hurts, because the larger picture, the overall piece, how it all works together is more important than those independent gems that are just a bit out of place.
But it still hurts.
